How long it takes: a couple hours but mostly hands off Equipment you’ll need: sharp knife, baking pan, skillet, mixing bowl Servings: 4 You just have to try this! I can’t say enough good about it. Make it tonight, you know your mouth is watering already. I know mine is. This is good eating, folks! Be sure to take a look at all my winter squash recipes!
The Best Stuffed Butternut Squash
Ultimate comfort food. For this recipe, I use butternut squash, quinoa, kale, and scallions. I throw in bacon and extra sharp white cheddar cheese for good measure. Everything here is so satisfying: the vibrant colors, the texture, and the taste. Good food and good for you. Just in case you need more convincing, squash is packed with nutrients and is low in calories. Antioxidants? Yup. Fiber? Yup. Vitamins and minerals? Yup. It has it all. Check it out at Healthline if you don’t believe me. We all know kale is like a superfood and quinoa is no slouch either. So you can feel really good eating this dish and your body will thank you. So you’re welcome! Time well spent. This recipe takes a little time to make. Butternut squash halves just need a fair amount of time to roast, there’s no getting around that. Most of the time is hands-off, though, and you can prep the quinoa and bacon while the squash roasts. The end result is so worth it!
Ingredient Notes
Butternut Squash: You’ll need a four pound squash, more or less. A butternut squash is a winter squash, tan in color and bell-shaped. It has sweet orange flesh. If you prefer, you can buy 2 smaller-sized squash so everyone gets their own half. Thick Cut Bacon: I like thick cut bacon because it provides meatier bites of bacon. You’ll need half a package (8 ounces). Kale: Dark green leafy kale is a nutrition powerhouse. Remove the tough stems by grasping the stem with one hand and running your other hand down the stem, pulling off the leafy part. Chop it pretty finely. Quinoa: Red quinoa contrasts nicely with the orange squash but any color is fine. (I used white quinoa when I photographed this recipe.) Make a big batch of quinoa and store it in the freezer to make recipes like this or these quinoa pancakes. Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese: This cheese has lots of flavor and works well with the bacon. Any type of cheese can be used though. Nutmeg, Thyme, Salt, and Pepper: Simple seasonings from your spice cupboard to flavor this fall dish. Scallions (Green Onions): For a fresh garnish!
How To Make Stuffed Squash
Prep the squash. Wash it thoroughly and use a heavy sharp knife to cut it in half vertically, from stem to blossom end. Scrape out the seeds and pulp. There’s no need to peel the squash for this recipe. Yaaay! Roast the squash. Rub a little oil on the cut side and sprinkle with salt and pepper. Place the squash cut side down on a parchment lined baking pan. Roast it until it’s fork tender, about an hour. Prep the stuffing. While the squash is roasting, you’ll have time to make the stuffing. Hopefully, you have some cooked quinoa on hand but don’t worry if you don’t. It’s so easy to make and only takes about 15 minutes. Just follow the package directions. Cook the bacon. Cut it into about 1 inch squares, nothing fancy. Cook the bacon in a large skillet until it’s crisp. Remove it from the pan, reserving a little of the grease. Put the bacon on a paper towel lined plate to drain off some of the grease. Cook the kale. Throw the kale in the frying pan next. Sauté it just until it softens and turns a really dark green. Set that aside for now. Shred the cheese if it isn’t shredded already. Prep the baked squash. When your squash is tender, remove it from the oven and carefully flip the halves over. If it’s just too hot for you to handle, go ahead and let it cool a few minutes. Gently scrape the cooked squash out, leaving about a half inch stuck to the shell. Put the squash flesh (doesn’t that sound gross?) into a large bowl and mash it slightly. Combine stuffing ingredients. Simply add all the other ingredients to the bowl with the squash and lightly toss it together. Stuff the squash halves. Scoop the mixture into the squash shells. There will be a lot of stuffing so go ahead and mound it up. Make little hills of stuffing in the squash. Bake. Put the squash halves back into the oven (you can use the same pan and parchment paper!). Bake them until the filling is piping hot. It will take a half hour or so. Don’t worry if gets a little brown and toasted on top, that’s really good! It’s crispy on top and so gooey and satisfying on the inside. Serve. Here you have choices: If you’re serving it as a main dish, cut each squash half into half again so everyone gets a quarter of the squash. For a side dish, you’ll want to slice it into smaller-sized pieces. It won’t be quite as pretty but if you’re careful and have a good sharp knife, you should be able to get attractive slices with the stuffing still attached.
Recipe Variations
This is one of those recipes that can be fiddled with and tweaked to your heart’s content. Make it the way you like or use what you happen to have.
Stuff another type of squash. Anything that can be stuffed will work whether it’s a big squash or a bunch of small ones. Really, this stuffing could be used in any type of squash. If you love the idea of stuffed squash, you have to try this amazing stuffed acorn squash, it’s one of my favorites! Choose a different meat. Instead of bacon, make it with sausage (Italian, breakfast, chorizo, chicken sausage links cut into circles), ham, or even ground beef. The meat should be cooked before adding it to the filling. Try a different cheese. Choose whatever cheese you like best or happen to have. Most any type of cheese will taste great here. Try it with feta! Make it vegetarian, vegan or dairy-free. Substitute great Northern or black beans if you want. Use vegan cheese or just omit the cheese entirely. Not a fan of quinoa? Use a different cooked grain such as farro, rice, brown rice, barley, bulgur, whatever you like. Seasonings: I chose a couple I really like but you can go in pretty much any direction you like. Try a little smoked paprika for a smoky flavor. Mix and match the veggies. Substitute any other leafy green for the kale. If you’re not into green, substitute another vegetable. Maybe corn is the only vegetable you like (besides squash, I guess). Corn will work! So will almost anything else. If you choose a firmer vegetable like onions or peppers, sauté them a little longer to soften them.
Time-Saving Ideas
Get a head start: Prep the squash and get it ready to roast up to a day ahead. Quinoa can be made ahead and frozen. Same with the bacon. Make ahead: The squash can be roasted and filled a day ahead of time. Refrigerate in a baking dish, covered tightly. To freeze, wrap the stuffed squash well and freeze it up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating. Bake the squash when ready to serve. It will take about 10 minutes longer since it’s cold.
Storage & Reheating Tips
Refrigerate/Freeze: Leftover stuffed squash can be covered and refrigerated for up to three days. It can be frozen up to one month. Thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating. Reheat: Microwave in one minute increments until heated through or heat in the oven at 350°F until heated through. Interested in a weekly meal plan that includes this recipe? Take a look at Meal Plan #86. You’ll find a wholesome recipe for each weekday plus a categorized grocery list. We add a new meal plan weekly. Quick-Start Guide!
