My Homemade Jalapeno Popper Recipe
These jalapeno poppers were inspired by one of my favorite snacks from back in the day when, as a teenager, I worked at a local Arby’s restaurant (this is where I actually met my husband!). These were one of my favorite items on the menu, and when I was pregnant with Luke, despite not having eaten there for years, they somehow became my #1 pregnancy craving (the number of times I burned my tongue biting into one of those bad boys is just too high). While many versions of this recipe include a savory dipping sauce or even forgo the sauce entirely, I knew I wanted to offer something different. I decided on a sweet and tangy raspberry sauce–obviously inspired by Arby’s Bronco Berry sauce–and I love the final combination! It’s an uncommon twist that is so tasty and provides a nice, tangy-sweet contrast to the spicy-savoriness of the jalapeno poppers.
What sets my recipe apart:
Blanching the jalapenos: This step keeps the jalapenos from being too crispy and makes them perfectly tender and easy to bite into. It also helps them cook evenly when fried. Flavorful filling: Many jalapeno popper recipes add no seasoning to their filling, using either just cream cheese or cheddar as the filling. I amp things up with a few additional spices for maximum flavor! Crispy coating: The double-dipping process in the egg/milk mixture and panko creates a deliciously crispy and golden exterior, adding texture to each bite. Unique dipping sauce: This sweet, berry filled sauce complements the spicy and creamy jalapeno poppers so well.
What You Need
I’m breaking up the ingredients visually here (left is the sauce, right is the jalapeno poppers themselves) and highlighting a few of the important ingredients below.
Jalapenos. How many you need will really depend on their size; I tend to prefer the smaller ones. Typically I find I need anywhere from 6-10 jalapenos to use up all of the filling. Remember to save some jalapeno for the raspberry dipping sauce if you’re making that too! Cream cheese. Make sure yours is softened before using it. To speed things up you could cut it into pieces and pop it in the microwave in 10-second intervals until it’s soft enough to stir. Spices. Including garlic powder, onion powder, smoked paprika, and ancho chili powder (a key ingredient in my potato soup). If you can’t find ancho chili powder, you can substitute chipotle chili powder or just leave it out entirely, but just note that the chipotle chili powder will be hotter and smokier. Panko. Make sure to use a plain, unseasoned panko. Note that we won’t be using the panko straight from the container; instead, we’ll break it up into smaller pieces to ensure a more even coating (I do this with my coconut shrimp, too, it’s a game changer). If you’d like to make your jalapeno poppers gluten free, you can use gluten free panko and all-purpose flour. Frozen raspberries. These are for the dipping sauce. You could also use fresh raspberries, just like in my raspberry sauce.
SAM’S TIP FOR CUSTOMIZABLE HEAT: How spicy these are really depends on the jalapenos you end up buying; some are just hotter than others. You can tweak the heat level of the poppers by removing more or less of the jalapeno seeds and membranes, adjusting the amount of ancho chili powder, or adding cayenne pepper to the filling.
How to Make Jalapeno Poppers
There are quite a few steps and I didn’t intend for this post to get so long, but I really wanted to provide a detailed visual guide along with the steps, below.
Make the Dipping Sauce
Prep the Jalapenos
Before we begin, a word of caution. I’m not someone who’s afraid of getting my hands dirty in the kitchen, but when it comes to cutting and cleaning out jalapenos I always wear gloves and I recommend you do the same. Your hands can absorb the capsaicin oil from the pepper, making them burn for days afterward. And if you accidentally touch your eyeball after cutting jalapenos… you’re going to have a bad time (ask me how I know!). These are the gloves I keep in my own kitchen; they’re also handy if you have to be hands on with garlic and don’t want your hands to smell afterwards!
Filling
Breading & Frying
SAM’S TIP: Don’t fry too many jalapenos at once, or you risk dropping your oil temperature too much. This can cause soggy, greasy jalapeno poppers–and no one wants that! I like to maximize my oil usage and I’ll often whip up a batch of mozzarella sticks with marinara to make the most of it. When you’re finished frying, cover the oil and let it cool completely before handling. Frying oil may be reused, but you’ll have to filter it (here is a guide on what to do with your oil once you’re done using it). You can reuse it or dispose of it properly — never pour it down the drain! We personally pour into a sealable container and then throw away). Are there any other restaurant dishes you’d to see recreated (like my pizookie)? Let me know in the comments! Enjoy! Let’s bake together! I’ll be walking you through all the steps in my written recipe below! If you try this recipe, be sure to tag me on Instagram, and you can also find me on YouTube and Facebook
Related Recipes
